PlayableNotes

Pathétique Adagio Cantabile, One Voice at a Time: Melody, Inner Line and Bass

Shirley Kirsten's post Patient voice-parceling in practicing Beethoven's Adagio Cantabile describes the movement as a "layer of voices that begs for a satisfying exploration". Her approach is to learn it "by individualizing voices, then permuting them, so they're understood in relation to each other before being integrated into a developed whole", first among "treble, tenor and bass lines", with patience and a slow tempo.

The first eight bars are built for that. Three things happen at once: a melody, a running line of semiquavers under it, and a bass. Below, each one plays alone, then in pairs, then all three together, so you can hear what each layer does before your hands have to balance them.

Every score here is the opening of the free PlayableNotes library edition, checked bar by bar against the Durand edition of 1915. Nothing has been changed except which voices are left in. Each one plays at any tempo and can loop a bar, with no account, and the whole movement prints free from its library page.

Step 1: each voice alone

The melody

The tune, in the middle of the keyboard, with nothing under it. Sing it, or play it until the shape of each phrase is clear: this is the line everything else has to stay beneath.

The player loads here.

The Pathétique Adagio, bars 1 to 8, the melody alone. Slow it down further if you like, or loop a bar.

The bass

The left hand's line, mostly two notes to a bar. Played alone it has its own shape, which is the "cello-like" bass Shirley Kirsten hears under the movement.

The player loads here.

The bass line of bars 1 to 8 on its own.

The inner semiquavers

The running semiquavers that fill the middle. In the score they belong to the right hand, under the melody, even though some editions print them on the lower staff. Alone, they show the harmony changing under the tune, which is the "harmonic rhythm" her post asks you to notice.

The player loads here.

The inner line of semiquavers, bars 1 to 8, with the melody and bass taken out.

Step 2: the voices in pairs

Her word is "permuting": each pair of voices together, so you hear how two of them fit before the third joins.

Melody and bass

The outer voices: the frame of the passage.

The player loads here.

The melody over the bass, without the inner line.

Inner line and bass

The accompaniment without the tune: everything the melody has to sing over.

The player loads here.

The inner semiquavers and the bass, bars 1 to 8.

Melody and inner line

What the right hand plays on its own: the melody on top and the semiquavers underneath, in one hand. This is where the balance is learned. Keep the semiquavers quieter than the tune.

The player loads here.

The right hand's two voices together: melody over semiquavers.

Step 3: all three together

Now the passage as written. If one layer gets lost, go back to the pair that holds it.

The player loads here.

Bars 1 to 8 as Beethoven wrote them, the three voices together.

Where a fourth layer joins

At bar 9 the melody returns an octave higher, and the left hand takes a line of semiquavers too, over its bass. The right hand now holds the melody and one line of semiquavers, and the left hand holds a second line of semiquavers and the bass: four layers, close to the four voices (soprano, alto, tenor, bass) that her post says the texture blossoms into. The same steps work here, one hand's two voices at a time.

Play “Bars 1 to 16, the theme and its return an octave higher” in the free library (bars 1–16 here).

The first sixteen bars from the library edition. From bar 9 both hands play semiquavers under the melody.

FAQ

Which hand plays the semiquavers at the start of the Pathétique second movement?

The right hand, under the melody, in bars 1 to 8. Some editions print them on the bass staff to save ledger lines, but they are still the right hand's. From bar 9 the left hand has semiquavers of its own as well.

What tempo should I practise the Pathétique Adagio at?

Slowly. It is marked Adagio, and one teaching guide suggests feeling the quaver, not the crotchet, as the pulse. The scores here start at 36 crotchets a minute, and the player goes lower.

Can I print the Pathétique second movement for free?

The whole movement prints from its library page. No account is needed.

← All posts