PlayableNotes

Fantaisie-Impromptu, four against three: play from one meeting note to the next

Lars Nelissen, a pianist and teacher in the Netherlands, uses Chopin's Fantaisie-Impromptu as his example in How to Play Polyrhythms on Piano. His advice for four against three: give both hands one shared beat, "find the note where both hands play together", tap each hand's rhythm on the closed lid while counting out loud, and then "play steadily, from one meeting note to the next."

This page is that step for the first entry of the right hand, bars 5 to 8. In every beat the right hand plays four sixteenths and the left hand three triplet eighths, and they meet on the beat.

The meeting notes alone

Here are only the notes where the hands meet: one per beat, as plain quarter notes. Play them hands together until you can find each one without looking, so both hands know where they are going.

The player loads here.

The notes each hand plays on each beat of bars 5 to 8. In bars 5, 6 and 7 the right hand rests on the first beat.

Notice the first beat of bars 5, 6 and 7. The left hand plays, but the right hand starts after a sixteenth rest, so its first meeting note in those bars is on beat 2. Only in bar 8 do the hands meet on all four beats. In bar 7 the meeting notes spread far apart: under the 8va the right hand reaches a high B on beat 3, and on beat 4 the left hand climbs to the A above middle C.

Bars 5 to 8 as printed

Now the same bars with every note. Play each hand alone first, as he does on the lid, then hands together slowly, aiming for the meeting notes you just practiced. When both hands land exactly together, raise the tempo a little.

The player loads here.

Bars 5 to 8 from the first edition of 1855. Use Right and Left to hear each hand alone, and loop a single bar.

He also suggests synchronizing the arms: the left hand moves in circles and the right hand follows it, down together and up together, even though the rhythms differ.

The theme's three attempts to rise

Ilinca Vartic, in her practice guide to the Fantaisie-Impromptu at Piano Career Academy, hears the main theme as three steps: a "first attempt to rise" in bar 5, a "second attempt" in bar 6, and "finally the successful wave with a complete rise-and-fall pattern" in bars 6 and 7. In the score, the right hand climbs to a G-sharp at the end of bar 5 and again at the end of bar 6. In bar 7 it rises to D-sharp and goes on, under the 8va, to the B on beat 3, the top of the wave, then falls away through bar 8.

The player loads here.

Bars 5 to 7 from the first edition of 1855. Loop bar 5, then bars 5 to 7, to hear the two short climbs and the full wave.

How this score was made and checked

The notes are from the first edition (Berlin, Schlesinger, 1855, edited by Julian Fontana), read note by note from the printed page. The meeting-notes score was made from it, and a script read both scores and confirmed that each beat holds exactly the notes the two hands start on that beat. Every bar plays at any tempo, one hand at a time or in a loop, and prints. In PlayableNotes a teacher can do the same with another passage and send it to a student as a practice link, which opens without an account.

← All posts