How Wide Does Piano Music Reach? We Measured 80 Pieces
In July, Stanford reported on research into the standard piano keyboard and hand size. A figure from a 2015 survey of 473 adult pianists kept coming up in the coverage: about 13 percent of women have a hand span large enough to play repeated, fast octaves comfortably on a standard keyboard.
That raises a practical question for anyone choosing music for a smaller hand. How much of the repertoire actually asks for a reach wider than an octave?
So we counted. We took 80 two-handed piano pieces from the PlayableNotes library, from Bach to Joplin, and measured every chord written on a single staff: the distance from its lowest note to its highest.
The short answer
67 of the 80 pieces never write a one-hand chord wider than an octave. 13 do, and all 13 were written after about 1820. A chord here is a set of notes on one stem. Two parts that one hand strikes together are a separate question, and we come to it under what this count doesn't see.
| Period | Pieces | No written chords in one hand | Widest chord under an octave | Widest chord exactly an octave | Wider than an octave |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baroque | 31 | 15 | 7 | 9 | 0 |
| Classical | 17 | 1 | 4 | 12 | 0 |
| Romantic | 19 | 0 | 4 | 6 | 9 |
| About 1890 to 1920 | 13 | 0 | 1 | 8 | 4 |
| All | 80 | 16 | 16 | 35 | 13 |
The Baroque pieces in this set never go past an octave. Fifteen of the 31 don't write a chord in one hand at all, because they are two lines moving against each other. The Classical pieces don't either: none of the 17 writes a chord wider than an octave in one hand.
The change comes with the Romantic pieces, where 9 of 19 write wider than an octave, and it carries on into Debussy, Satie and Scriabin, where 4 of the 13 pieces from about 1890 to 1920 do.
An octave limit is not an easy limit
Stanford's figure is about repeated, fast octaves, and the count above doesn't make those go away. A piece can stay inside an octave and still ask for a lot of them:
- The Entertainer never goes wider than an octave and writes 282 octaves, 184 of them on the right-hand staff.
- Maple Leaf Rag writes 282 too, 155 of them on the left-hand staff.
- Turkish March has 130 on the right-hand staff.
Meanwhile Für Elise writes 3 octaves in this edition and Sonata facile, K. 545 writes 12, all in the left hand. If octaves are what hurts, the count of them matters as much as the widest chord. The full data has both for every piece.
The 13 pieces that go wider
| Piece | Widest written chord | Where | Chords wider than an octave |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mazeppa (1839 version) (Liszt) | 31 half steps (two hands, or rolled) | bar 169, left-hand staff | 12 |
| Prelude in E Minor, Op. 28 No. 4 (Chopin) | 31 half steps (two hands, or rolled) | bar 26, left-hand staff | 3 |
| Fantaisie-Impromptu, Op. 66 (Chopin) | 23 half steps (two hands, or rolled) | bar 137, left-hand staff | 8 |
| Left-Hand Prelude and Nocturne (Scriabin) | 17 half steps (eleventh) | bar 56, left-hand staff | 25 |
| Ballade No. 1 in G Minor, Op. 23 (Chopin) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 246, left-hand staff | 9 |
| Arabesques No. 1 and No. 2 (Debussy) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 112, left-hand staff | 18 |
| Clair de Lune, L. 75 (Debussy) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 26, left-hand staff | 2 |
| Gnomenreigen, S. 145 No. 2 (Liszt) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 126, left-hand staff | 6 |
| Nocturne Op. 9 No. 2 (Chopin) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 35, left-hand staff | 1 |
| The Seasons, January (At the Fireside) | 16 half steps (tenth) | bar 43, left-hand staff | 7 |
| Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 (Liszt) | 15 half steps (minor tenth) | bar 96, right-hand staff | 6 |
| Gymnopédie No. 1 (Satie) | 14 half steps (ninth) | bar 24, left-hand staff | 6 |
| The Seasons, February (Carnival) | 14 half steps (ninth) | bar 160, right-hand staff | 8 |
Four half steps above an octave is a major tenth, a stretch often named in writing about large hands. Ten of these pieces reach it or go past it on the left-hand staff.
A few of the numbers are too wide for one hand to strike. The last chord of Chopin's Prelude in E Minor spans 31 half steps on the page, so it is either shared between the hands or rolled from the bottom up. This edition doesn't say which, and neither does the count. Scriabin's Op. 9 is written for the left hand alone, so its wide chords, up to an eleventh at bar 56, are one hand's work spread out in time. Debussy marks both of the tenths in Clair de Lune, in bars 26 and 72, to be rolled, and Liszt marks the tenth in Gnomenreigen at bar 126 the same way.
What this count doesn't see
Treat these numbers as a map, not a verdict.
- It counts chords, not broken chords. A left-hand arpeggio that opens out over a tenth, as in much of Chopin, doesn't appear here, because its notes are written one after another. The hand still has to travel.
- It counts one stem at a time. A melody note struck over an inner part, or a bass note under a tenor note, can be further apart than any chord on the page. When we read those places in print for Beethoven's 32 sonatas, eight sonatas turned out to ask for a wider stretch than their chords showed. In this set, 13 of the 67 pieces that stay within an octave have a place in the library's edition where two parts on one staff are struck more than an octave apart. We read the ten that aren't by Bach in their printed editions. Three ask one hand for more than an octave as printed: the Moonlight Sonata's first movement (a ninth in the right hand, bars 8, 16 and 18 of the Durand edition), Scriabin's Prelude in E-flat minor (a ninth in the right hand, bars 4 and 5 of the Belaieff first edition, 1897) and Debussy's Rêverie (a tenth in the left hand, bar 54 of the Fromont edition, 1905). In The Entertainer (bars 58 and 66 of the Stark first edition, 1902) the right hand holds a tenth without striking it, keeping B-flat above the staff down while it plays the G below. In the other six, the place belongs to the other hand or is a wrong note in the library's copy. The three by Bach split their voices between the staves without fingering, so we have left them out of this check.
- It follows the staff, not the hand. Editors decide which notes go on which staff, and a pianist can move a note to the other hand. A chord counted as left-hand may be divided in practice.
- It reads one edition of each piece. Every piece here is a public-domain edition in our library, and other editions may lay a passage out differently.
- It is a sample. These 80 are the two-handed pieces in our library that aren't melody-only arrangements, hymn tunes or song accompaniments. It leans toward pieces students play.
What to do with a chord you can't reach
For a chord that goes past your reach, there are three standard changes, and each keeps the harmony:
- Roll it, from the bottom note up, with the pedal holding what your fingers release.
- Give a note to the other hand, if that hand is free at that moment.
- Leave out a note that another hand is already playing, or the inner note of an octave doubling.
Here is the second change on a real bar. The final chord of Chopin's Nocturne Op. 9 No. 2, at bar 35, has E-flat, B-flat and G on the left-hand staff, a tenth from bottom to top. The right hand holds a single E-flat above it at that moment, so it can take the G as well. The left hand keeps the bottom two notes, a fifth apart, and every note still sounds.
In PlayableNotes you can make that change without rewriting the page: open a piece from the library, choose Edit a copy, and describe the change you want, such as "move the top note of the left-hand chord in bar 35 to the right hand". You can then play it through, print it, or send it to a student as a practice link. Editing a copy needs a free account. Playing and printing the library pieces don't.
How we counted
For each piece we read the score the library plays and took every chord written in a single voice on one staff. We measured the distance in half steps from the lowest to the highest note, with key signatures, accidentals and octave signs applied. An octave is 12 half steps. Four chords are counted as their printed editions have them, where the library's copy differs: the left-hand octave in bar 7 of the Moonlight Sonata's first movement (Durand, 1915), the left-hand F octave in bar 20 of Pine Apple Rag (Seminary Music, 1908), the left-hand chord D, A, C, F-sharp in bar 246 of Chopin's Ballade No. 1 (Breitkopf und Härtel, 1836) and the rolled chord in bar 137 of the Fantaisie-Impromptu, which has no low C-sharp under the left hand's C-sharp and G-sharp in the first edition (Schlesinger, 1855). We left out melody-only arrangements, hymn tunes, song accompaniments and transcriptions of pieces for other instruments, which left the 80 pieces here.
The figures for every piece are in this CSV file, with a link to each score so you can check a bar for yourself.
FAQ
Which well-known piano pieces stay within an octave?
Of the 80 we measured, Für Elise, Turkish March, The Entertainer, Maple Leaf Rag and Bach's Prelude in C Major, BWV 933 never write a chord on one stem wider than an octave.
Does the Moonlight Sonata need big hands?
No chord on one stem in its first movement is wider than an octave. But the right hand also carries the melody over the triplets, and in a few bars it strikes a melody note a ninth above the triplet's first note: in bars 16 and 18 of the Durand edition, C-natural over the B below. The movement also writes 101 octaves on the left-hand staff, so a hand that finds octaves tiring will notice them.
Are Bach and Mozart better for small hands?
In this set, none of the 31 Baroque pieces and none of the 17 Classical pieces wrote a chord on one stem wider than an octave. The count doesn't cover speed or awkward fingering.