PlayableNotes

Chopin's Prelude in E Minor: the Still Melody and the Restless Chords, Heard Apart

Leo Ravera's analysis of this prelude, Chopin Prelude op.28 no.4, how to create tension with melody and harmony, rests on a contrast. The melody "moves little, almost nothing", while the harmony "is never quiet, with constantly changing chords, not resolving the tension", and there are only two places where a dominant chord resolves to E minor. On the page the two layers sit together. Below they are pulled apart, so you can hear each one by itself, then the two places where the tension is released, then the whole piece.

The melody alone

The right hand exactly as printed, with the left hand silent. From bar 2 to bar 9 it uses only five pitches, G-sharp up to C, and from bar 14 to bar 16 only two, B and C. It breaks out in three places: bar 10, the flourish of bar 13, and bars 17 to 19, where it climbs to C6 in bar 18, the highest note in the piece. Then, from bar 21 to the end, it is down to three pitches again: E, F-sharp and D-sharp.

The player loads here.

The right hand of Chopin's Prelude in E minor as printed, with the left hand silent. Slow it down, loop a bar or print it.

Played like this, the melody sounds almost like a single held note with small sighs around it. That is the point of the contrast: the expression has to come from somewhere else.

The left hand alone

Now the other layer: every left-hand chord as printed, with the melody silent. Listen for how often the chord shifts under a melody note that stays put. From bar 3 to bar 9, every change moves just one note of the chord down a half step, so the harmony keeps sliding without arriving. The left hand blocked page holds each run of repeated chords as one chord and lists every one of those moves.

The player loads here.

Every left-hand chord of the prelude as printed, with the melody silent.

The two cadences

Leo Ravera hears only two perfect cadences, B7 to E minor: one halfway through and one at the end. The first comes in bar 13, where, as he notes, the left hand stops playing chords and leaves the melody alone; one left-hand chord, B, D-sharp and A, sounds on the first beat under the flourish, and bar 14 returns to E minor and the opening.

Play “Prelude in E Minor, bars 12 to 14” in the free library (bars 12–14 here).

The first cadence, halfway through the prelude: B7 in bar 13 resolves to E minor at the start of bar 14.

The second comes in bars 25 and 26, after the music stops halfway through bar 24, and the prelude finally settles in E minor.

Play “Prelude in E Minor, bars 24 to 26” in the free library (bars 24–26 here).

The final cadence of the prelude, bars 24 to 26.

The whole prelude

Put the two layers back together. Knowing that the melody barely moves, and that the chords underneath almost never resolve, is a good guide to where to lean and where to wait: the first cadence in bar 13, the climb to bar 18, and the final cadence in bars 25 and 26.

Play “Prelude in E Minor, Op. 28 No. 4” in the free library.

Chopin's Prelude in E minor as written, from the free PlayableNotes library.

For the chord names, bar by bar, and the unusual chords Chopin uses along the way, read Leo Ravera's full analysis, which also offers his annotated score to download.

How it was made and checked

The notes are the PlayableNotes library edition of the prelude, which we compared with the first German edition (Breitkopf und Härtel, Leipzig, about 1839) in all 26 bars. The melody score is that edition's right hand with the left hand silent, and the left-hand score is the reverse. A script reads both against the original through the same parser the site uses and matches every note, bar by bar. The pitch counts above come from the same edition.

Every score here plays at any tempo, one hand at a time or with a passage on loop, and prints, with no account. In PlayableNotes you can make practice versions like these of other pieces, and send one to a student as a practice link that opens without an account.

← All posts