PlayableNotes

Chopin's Ballade No. 1: the Long Descending Run, Slowed Down and Heard Over Its Chords

Rachel Billings's short tutorial, Chopin Ballade No.1: how to fix a tricky descending scale run, offers two ways in. One is to "slow the passage down and group the notes mentally, while keeping the notes themselves even." The other is to understand the harmony underneath: "F7, followed by chord iv (notice that it's minor, not major), then V and I in E-flat major." This page puts both in front of you as scores you can play: first the run by itself at any tempo, then the whole passage with its chords, bars 162 to 167 of the Ballade.

The run alone

Only the notes of the run, with everything else silent. It is 42 eighth notes, each one lower than the one before, from F7 down to C-flat 2: five and a half octaves. The right hand plays the first 29, and the left hand takes the last 13, from the final eighth of bar 164.

The player loads here.

The descending run from Chopin's Ballade No. 1, bars 162 to 165, with every other note silent. Slow it down, play one hand, or loop a bar.

For grouping the notes, the first edition (Breitkopf und Härtel, Leipzig, 1836) already gives one answer: it beams the whole run in groups of six. That makes seven groups, one in bar 162 and two in each of the next three bars. In bar 164 the second group crosses from the right hand to the left, so the change of hand falls on the last note of a group, and the left hand then starts a fresh group of its own in bar 165.

Start the player slow enough that every group of six is even, then raise the tempo a few steps at a time. As Rachel Billings puts it, listen "for evenness and clarity rather than simply trying to play faster."

The passage with its chords

Now bars 162 to 167 as printed. The four chords she names are all in the left hand:

  • F7 in bar 162: C, E-flat, F and A, struck on the fourth beat, as the run begins.
  • Chord iv, A-flat minor at the start of bar 164: C-flat, E-flat, A-flat and E-flat, where the C-flat is what makes it minor.
  • V, B-flat in bar 166: the left hand breaks a B-flat chord, B-flat, F and D, under the right hand's chords.
  • I, E-flat in bar 167: E-flat, B-flat and G in the left hand.

The run follows the change of chord. In bars 162 and 163 it passes through E natural three times, each one followed straight away by E-flat. From bar 164 there is no E natural at all, and C-flat, D-flat and G-flat appear for the first time; the run touches C-flat four times on the way down.

The player loads here.

Chopin's Ballade No. 1, bars 162 to 167 as printed: F7, the run, A-flat minor, then B-flat and E-flat.

Try the left hand alone first and listen for the four chords, then add the right hand. To hear the passage in context, Rachel Billings links her full performance from her tutorial; the run comes at about the seven-minute mark.

How it was made and checked

The notes are the PlayableNotes library edition of the Ballade, which we read note by note against the 1836 Breitkopf und Härtel first edition for these six bars. That check found two wrong left-hand notes in the library copy, an A natural in bar 164 that the print has as A-flat, and a D in bar 166 that the print has as F. Both are corrected here. A script reads the two scores above through the same parser the site uses: the passage matches the corrected edition in every bar, and the run score holds only notes from the passage. The counts above come from the same script.

Every score here plays at any tempo, one hand at a time or with a passage on loop, and prints, with no account. In PlayableNotes you can make practice versions like these of other pieces, and send one to a student as a practice link that opens without an account.

← All posts