PlayableNotes

Bach's Prelude in C Minor, BWV 847, in Block Chords

Ruth Pheasant's Bach Prelude in C Minor piano tutorial points out that the piece "consists of repeated broken chord patterns throughout," and that "it can be helpful to practise the piece as block chords," so the hand learns where each bar sits before playing it at speed. She suggests doing the same with the left hand, and practising C minor scales, "both melodic and harmonic versions," and E flat major, the relative major. Here are those, as scores you can play and print.

Bars 1 to 24 in block chords

In each of bars 1 to 24, each hand plays the same group of eight sixteenths twice. The group is a broken chord with one in-between note, the note just below the one the hand keeps returning to. Here each group is played as one chord of its other three notes, two chords a bar.

The player loads here.

Bars 1 to 24 of Bach's Prelude in C minor with each hand's broken chord played together, twice a bar. In bar 1 the right hand plays C, E flat and the C above, and the left hand C, E flat and G. Use Right or Left to practise one hand at a time.

From bar 25 the figures change: three bars of a single line climbing out of the bass, then the Presto at bar 28, the Adagio at bar 34 and the closing Allegro, so those bars are best learned as written.

The skeleton: melody, counter-note and bass

Wim Winters, in Beyond the Notes: Bach's Prelude in C Minor will make you smile, strips away the sixteenths to leave "a skeleton of just a few notes": a bass note and the melody on the first and third beats, with a counter-note on the second and fourth. The first interval, he points out, is a descending octave. He suggests playing the skeleton on its own "to experience the change in character of the piece." Here it is for bars 1 to 24, taken from the first note of each beat.

The player loads here.

The first note of each beat in bars 1 to 24: in the right hand the melody note on beats 1 and 3 and the counter-note on beats 2 and 4, in the left hand the bass. Bar 1 opens with the descending octave, C down to the C below. In bars 19 and 20 the right hand's first note is the lower of the two.

The scales

C harmonic minor, C melodic minor and E flat major, one octave up and down with the hands an octave apart. The melodic minor goes up with A natural and B natural and comes down with B flat and A flat.

The player loads here.

C harmonic minor, one octave up and down, hands together: C, D, E flat, F, G, A flat, B natural, C.

The player loads here.

C melodic minor, hands together: up with A natural and B natural, down with B flat and A flat.

The player loads here.

E flat major, the relative major of C minor, one octave up and down, hands together.

The ending, bars 25 to 38

Yuliya Borshchova, who teaches this prelude to intermediate adult students, writes in Bach's Prelude No. 2 in C Minor: The Piece That Sounds Like Life Itself about the moment where "the constant motion gives way to something wider," and hears "the final E natural" as "a light at the end of the tunnel." Here are the last fourteen bars on their own, where the music changes most:

  • Bars 25 and 26: the right hand drops out and the left hand plays alone.
  • Bar 28, Presto: the right hand runs over a low G that the left hand holds for the whole bar.
  • Bar 34, Adagio: for one bar the steady sixteenths stop. The left hand plays two chords, and the right hand a line with a trill and fast 32nd and 64th notes.
  • Bars 35 to 37, Allegro: the left hand alone again, until the right hand comes back in bar 38.
  • Bar 38: the last right-hand note is E natural, held under a fermata over C in the bass. After a piece in C minor, that one note makes the final chord major.

The player loads here.

The last fourteen bars of Bach's Prelude in C minor as written. The Presto, Adagio and Allegro are marked above the staff; the player keeps one tempo, so set it by hand for each.

The prelude as written

The player loads here.

Bach's Prelude in C minor as written, checked against the Bach-Gesellschaft edition of 1866 in all 38 bars. The score plays at one tempo; the edition's Presto (bar 28), Adagio (bar 34) and Allegro (bar 35) are marked above the staff, and the arpeggio signs in bar 34 are left out.

How it was made and checked

The notes come from the Center for Computer Assisted Research in the Humanities' encoding of the Bach-Gesellschaft edition (Leipzig, 1866), converted to a PlayableNotes score and read back through the app's own reader note by note. We then read the score against the printed edition in all 38 bars. In the fast run of bar 34 the edition prints A flat twice where the encoding has A natural, and the score follows the edition. The block chords are built from the score by a script that first checks that every one of bars 1 to 24 holds the same pattern, so each chord is exactly its bar's notes without the in-between note. The skeleton is the first note of each beat, taken from the same score by a script and read back through the app's reader.

Each score plays with one hand at a time, a bar on loop, or at any tempo, and prints. You can make practice versions like these for other music in PlayableNotes: open a copy of a piece and describe the change in the chat, for example "play each group as a block chord". The result can be sent to a student as a practice link, which they open without an account.

← All posts