PlayableNotes

The Star-Spangled Banner and America for the Piano Proficiency: Melody and Chords in the Keys Exams Ask For

Many piano proficiency exams ask music majors to play the songs a teacher gets asked for without warning. Kutztown University's Piano Proficiency page asks for patriotic songs "from memory", among them the "Star Spangled Banner in the keys of Bb and Ab", "America the Beautiful in the keys of C and Bb" and "America in the keys of F and Eb". This page writes those out, and Auld Lang Syne with them, melody in the right hand over block chords in the left, as scores you can play, slow down, loop a phrase at a time and print.

Star Spangled Banner in the keys of B-flat and A-flat

Why those two keys? The Army Song Book of 1918, which printed the version of the song agreed that year for the services and for schools, says under the music: "In the band book of accompaniments the Star Spangled Banner is given in two keys, Bb and Ab. The key of Ab is optional for singing only, as Bb is the generally accepted key for bands and ceremonial use." Exams still follow it: B-flat is where a band plays it, and A-flat puts the top note a step lower for a room of singers.

The melody below is the one in that book. In B-flat it runs from the B-flat below middle C up to the F at the top of the staff, an octave and a fifth, which is why the tune is hard to sing and why the lower key exists.

The player loads here.

The Star-Spangled Banner in B-flat major, the melody of the 1918 Army Song Book over left-hand block chords.

The player loads here.

The same in A-flat major, a whole step lower.

Star Spangled Banner in A, at a tempo for community or classroom singing

Cal State San Bernardino's music department handbook asks for the "Star Spangled Banner in keys of Bb, A" and America "in keys F, G, Eb", and adds: "Tempo should be suitable for community or classroom singing." A major is a half step below B-flat, so the melody runs from the A below middle C to the E in the top space of the treble staff. The left hand uses the same five chord shapes as in the other keys; in A, the V7 of V is A, B and D-sharp.

The player loads here.

The Star-Spangled Banner in A major, the melody of the 1918 Army Song Book over left-hand block chords.

The score plays at 104 to the quarter note, the marking in the 1918 book. Slow it down to learn it, then work back up until a room could sing with you without waiting for the piano.

Right-hand melody and left-hand primary chords, including V7 of V

Some handbooks say how the hands should share the work. Friends University's music student handbook asks students to "Play Star Spangled Banner in Bb Major at singing tempo with right hand melody and left-hand primary chords including V7 of V." That is how the two scores above are written. The left hand needs five shapes, all in closest position so the hand hardly moves:

Chord In B-flat (low to high) In A-flat (low to high) Scale degrees
I B-flat, D, F A-flat, C, E-flat 1, 3, 5
IV B-flat, E-flat, G A-flat, D-flat, F 1, 4, 6
V7 A, E-flat, F G, D-flat, E-flat 7, 4, 5
V A, C, F G, B-flat, E-flat 7, 2, 5
V7 of V B-flat, C, E natural A-flat, B-flat, D natural 1, 2, raised 4

V7 of V is the one chord from outside the key, and the melody tells you where it goes: it falls on the three notes the tune itself raises, at "ear-ly", "per-il-ous" and "was still". The right hand plays E natural (in B-flat) or D natural (in A-flat), the left hand keeps the tonic at the bottom and moves its two upper notes down a step, and the next bar lands on V at "light", "fight" and "there".

Where the chords change, phrase by phrase:

Words Chords, one per bar unless shown
O say can you see, by the dawn's early light I, I, I then V7 of V, V
What so proudly we hailed at the twilight's last gleaming I, V7, I, I
Whose broad stripes and bright stars, through the perilous fight I, I, I then V7 of V, V
O'er the ramparts we watched were so gallantly streaming I, V7, I, I
And the rockets' red glare, the bombs bursting in air I, I, V7, V7
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there I, V7, I then V7 of V, V
O say does that Star-Spangled Banner yet wave I, IV, V7, I then V
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave I, I, I then V7, I

IV appears only once, under "Star-Spangled". Everything else is I, V, V7 and that one V7 of V, which is what makes the piece learnable in a second key: the left hand's plan is the same list of numerals.

A fluent performance, with proper pedaling

Rutgers' Mason Gross School of the Arts asks, in its piano proficiency packet, for "A fluent performance of the Star-Spangled Banner in A-flat Major, with proper pedaling". Two things get you there.

Fluent means the pulse never stops. The places it usually does are the leap up at "see" and the climb through "rockets' red glare". Loop each of those in the score (click its first bar, then its last) at a slow tempo until the right hand finds the top note without a gap, and only then put the left hand back.

Pedaling follows the chords, not the melody. Change the pedal just after each new left-hand chord sounds: the foot comes up as the chord goes down and returns at once. In most bars that is one change, on beat one. Where a bar has two chords, at "early", "perilous", "was still", "wave" and "home of the", change on both. If the melody blurs in the stepwise bars ("bursting in air"), take a shallower pedal, not a later one.

America in the keys of F, E-flat and G

Kutztown also asks for "America in the keys of F and Eb", Cal State San Bernardino for America "in keys F, G, Eb", and Friends for "America or Happy Birthday in G Major at singing tempo with right hand melody and left-hand primary chords". The tune is fourteen bars and needs only I, IV and V7, in the same closest-position shapes as above. IV comes once, on the first beat of the second-last bar ("Let" in "Let freedom ring"), where the three beats go IV, I, V7.

The player loads here.

America in F major, melody over left-hand I, IV and V7.

The player loads here.

The same in E-flat major.

The player loads here.

The same in G major, the key the 1918 Army Song Book prints it in.

America with waltz bass and Alberti bass

Southern Illinois University Edwardsville's class piano proficiency test asks, for Mus 121B, to "Harmonize and accompany a melody with Alberti Bass and Waltz Bass." Here is America in F both ways. The chords are the ones above, one per bar, with IV, I and V7 on the three beats of the second-last bar. Only the left hand's pattern changes.

Waltz bass puts the root low on beat one and the chord in closest position on beats two and three.

The player loads here.

America in F major, melody over a waltz bass: root on beat one, chord on beats two and three.

Alberti bass breaks the same chord into eighth notes: lowest, highest, middle, highest, middle, highest. In the second-last bar, where the chord changes on every beat, each beat gets its lowest and highest notes only, and the last bar is a held chord.

The player loads here.

America in F major, melody over an Alberti bass on the same chords.
Chord Waltz bass: root, then chord Alberti bass: low, high, middle, high
I F, then F, A, C F, C, A, C
V7 C, then E, B-flat, C E, C, B-flat, C
IV (second-last bar, beat one) B-flat F, D

Play each pattern on the chords alone first, saying the numerals, then add the tune. In the Alberti bass the top note comes back every other eighth: keep it light so the melody stays on top.

America the Beautiful in the keys of C and B-flat

The third song in Kutztown's sentence is "America the Beautiful in the keys of C and Bb". The tune is Samuel A. Ward's "Materna". The Golden Book of Favorite Songs, in its 1923 edition, says the words "have been sung to numerous tunes", and that Ward's is "the best known". It prints the song in C, sixteen bars in four-four time after a one-beat pickup.

The player loads here.

America the Beautiful in C major, the melody of the 1923 Golden Book of Favorite Songs over left-hand block chords.

The player loads here.

The same in B-flat major, a whole step lower.

The left hand uses the same five shapes as the Banner. Where the chords change, one entry per bar:

Words Chords
O beautiful for spacious skies, for amber waves of grain I; V7 then I on beat four; IV then V on beat four; I
For purple mountain majesties above the fruited plain I; V; V then V7 of V from beat two; V then V7 on beat four
America, America, God shed His grace on thee I; IV, V7, I; V7; I
And crown thy good with brotherhood from sea to shining sea IV; I; IV, I, V7; I

The one note from outside the key comes at "above": C-sharp in C major, B natural in B-flat. It is a leaning note. The left hand plays V under it, the melody steps up to the chord note on beat two, and there the left hand moves to V7 of V for the rest of the bar before settling on V at "plain".

A prepared harmonization of Auld Lang Syne

West Virginia University's graduate piano proficiency exam asks for a "Prepared harmonization of the following melodies: Star Spangled Banner Happy Birthday Auld Lang Syne". The Banner is harmonized above and Happy Birthday below. Auld Lang Syne needs only I, IV and V7.

The Golden Book prints it in F. The tune dips to the fifth below the tonic, so the left hand sits low, well clear of the melody.

The player loads here.

Auld Lang Syne in F major, the melody of the 1923 Golden Book of Favorite Songs over left-hand I, IV and V7.

The player loads here.

The same in G major, a whole step higher.
Words Chords, one entry per bar
Should auld acquaintance be forgot, and never brought to mind I; V7 then I on beat four; I; IV
Should auld acquaintance be forgot, and days of auld lang syne I; V7 then I on beat four; IV then V7 on beat four; I then IV on beat four
For auld lang syne, my dear, for auld lang syne I; V7; I; IV
We'll take a cup of kindness yet for auld lang syne I; V7 then I on beat four; IV then V7 on beat four; I

The four lines share one plan: I, V7, I, IV, then I, V7, IV to V7, I. Learn the first two lines and the refrain is already in the hands.

Happy Birthday in G and F

Happy Birthday is on WVU's list too, and Friends University asks for "America or Happy Birthday in G Major at singing tempo with right hand melody and left-hand primary chords". The tune is "Good-Morning to All" by Mildred J. Hill, which the 1896 edition of Song Stories for the Kindergarten prints in G. The birthday words put two syllables where the morning song has one, so each pickup is played as two notes on the same pitch, long then short.

The player loads here.

Happy Birthday in G major, the tune as Song Stories for the Kindergarten (1896) prints it, over left-hand I, IV and V7.

The player loads here.

The same in F major, a whole step lower.

It is eight bars and one chord a bar until the end: I, V7, V7, I, then I, IV, I with V7 on beat three, I. Three downbeats lean: at the first "birthday", the second "birthday" and the name, the melody starts a step above a chord note and falls to it on beat two. Play the chord firmly on the beat and let the melody resolve over it.

Happy Birthday in F with a waltz-style accompaniment

Rutgers' piano proficiency packet sets Happy Birthday a different task in Area 5: "Play and Sing “Happy Birthday” with waltz-style accompaniment in the key of F Major". It explains the pattern: "right-hand chords and left-hand single notes (L-R-R, L-R-R, …)". The voice carries the tune, so the piano plays no melody. The left hand plays the root of the chord on beat one, and the right hand answers with the chord on beats two and three.

The player loads here.

Waltz-style accompaniment in F major for singing: the left hand on beat one, right-hand chords on beats two and three. The voice sings the tune.

The packet's page of directions asks for "nearby chords", so the right hand keeps three shapes that hardly move:

Chord Right hand (low to high) Left hand
I C, F, A F
V7 C, E, B-flat C
IV D, F, B-flat B-flat

From I to V7 the C stays, F falls to E and A rises to B-flat. From I to IV, C and A each rise a step and F stays. The plan is the one in the section above: I, V7, V7, I, then I, IV, I with V7 on beat three, I. The pickup is sung alone and the piano comes in on "birth".

On beats two and three, the note being sung is always in the right-hand chord, so the hand that keeps the waltz going also holds the singer's pitch. Learn the accompaniment alone first, then sing over it slowly. If the voice drifts, play the chords louder than feels right.

Playing them from memory

  1. Memorize the left hand as numerals first, from the table above, and say them aloud while playing the chords alone. The numerals are the same in every key.
  2. Learn the melody a phrase at a time with the score, then with the score hidden. The first two lines of the Banner share one melody, so there is less to learn than it seems.
  3. Put the hands together slowly in the first key. Then play the second key from memory before you look at its score, and use the score to check what you played.
  4. Work up to singing tempo. The 1918 book marks the Banner at 104 to the quarter note, easing to 96 at "O say does that Star-Spangled Banner".

How it was made and checked

The melodies are read from the Army Song Book issued in Washington in 1918, and for America the Beautiful and Auld Lang Syne from The Golden Book of Favorite Songs (Chicago, 1923), and for Happy Birthday from Song Stories for the Kindergarten (Chicago, 1896), all public-domain prints. The left-hand chords are our own. We wrote each song once by scale degree, made the score in each key with PlayableNotes, and checked every note automatically from what the player reads: the melody matches the printed pitches and rhythms in every key, each left-hand chord has the right notes and sits below the melody, and the melody note on each chord change belongs to the chord, apart from the leaning notes pointed out above. The scores play at any tempo, one hand at a time, and print with no account. In PlayableNotes you can also move any piano score to another key by describing the change you want, such as "move it to G major".

For the chord progressions the same exams ask for, see I-IV-I-V-I in keyboard style and the other proficiency progressions in all keys.

← All posts